by Charlie Chester, Digital

If you’re a music lover, still think tape cassettes are cool, or at any point in your life have owned a guitar, you may have recently read the news that the meteoric rise of Brooklyn band Geese is, to some degree, the result of a marketing agency exploiting social media loopholes to generate hype. 

The story, brought to light by musician and critic Eliza McLamb, revealed how the agency managed fake fan accounts, seeded content showcasing the band’s music, and leveraged a network of influencers to simulate a trend from the ground up. For anyone who follows music closely, Geese’s trajectory was hard to ignore – one minute relatively unknown, the next topping end-of-year lists across the board. 

As an agency built around the idea of Relative Advantage, it’d be hard for us not to clock what was happening here – infiltrating community and simulating immense share of audience. Whatever you think of the ethics, it’s an ingenious piece of work – a deep understanding of how organic social functions, applied with precision to game the algorithm. 

But here’s where it gets interesting.

In an era where cultural capital is arguably as valuable as its financial counterpart, and in a subculture where people pride themselves on their carefully curated taste (see the rise of ‘tastemaxxing’), the backlash was inevitable. Finding out that the coolest band you’d stumbled upon wasn’t entirely a product of your own discernment stings in a particular way. 

Finding a Relative Advantage isn’t about cutting corners or gaming a system until it breaks. It’s about understanding your audience well enough to meet them somewhere unexpected, somewhere the competition hasn’t thought to look yet. When we worked with Tequila Rose, that meant identifying pre-drinks as a moment to connect with nights out, not the bar or the club. 

And that’s the crucial difference with what happened to Geese. The Relative Advantage their agency found was real, and for a while it worked brilliantly. But it was built on a foundation that couldn’t hold scrutiny. When it came to light, the people who lost out weren’t the agency or even the label, it was the fans. The ones who’d felt that rare thrill of discovering something brilliant, only to have the discovery called into question. That’s a hard thing to come back from. 

A specific ‘instance’ of Relative Advantage may have a shelf life. Markets shift, competitors catch up, platforms change the rules. The goal isn’t necessarily to find a loophole, it’s to find an edge, and build something worth standing behind. I still like Geese’s music. I’m just not sure I’ll ever see them as the edgy outsiders they appeared to be. Which is an important reminder that authenticity still matters and that Relative Advantage has more integrity than playing the system.